• RICHARD ERIKSSON
  • FLICKR
  • TWITTER

Just a Gwai Lo - fun within prescribed limits

  • home
  • about
  • ideas
  • photos
  • cherished
  • shared
  • contact
  • recent
Home

Why the United States is Bad at Empire

June 4, 2004

Niall Ferguson: “A very large proportion of Americans don't have passports. But even more striking to me is the fact that the kind of people you might expect to be well-equipped to engage in what we rather euphemistically call nation-building—that's to say, the graduates of the elite universities—disproportionately avoid overseas engagements. The ambitions of the educational elite in this country are quite domestically focused. They really would rather be running a Wall Street law firm than governing Baghdad. And I think that's a fundamental social-cultural reason why the United States is bad at empire.”

In the following paragraph, Ferguson makes a very interesting point about drafting soldiers (which I oppose on the grounds that it weakens the army because volunteers are more likely to follow orders than those there unwillingly). He says that when you draft people in the military, you increase the likelihood that soldiers will have a diverse range of talents, and these talents came into play during the post-WWII period nation-building in Germany and Japan because soldiers were drawn from more walks of life than those who would join the army anyway.

tags: Niall Ferguson, military draft
Syndicate content

Related photos

  • Phillip Jeffrey Demonstrates Facebook at 2007 Northern Voice Moosecamp
  • Concentration
  • Kris Krug Takes Anil Dash's Picture During Northern Voice 2007
  • Looking Up From the UBC Forestry Sciences Building During Northern Voice
  • Will Pate at Moosecamp's Session for a Prospective Vancouver TransitCamp
  • Karen at Moosecamp's Session for a Prospective Vancouver TransitCamp
  • Happy Richard At Work
  • Serious Richard At Work
  • Richard At Work
  • Boris Mann at Subeez
  • Boris and His Scare Quotes at Subeez
  • Darren Barefoot at Subeez
  • Profile At Subeez
  • Me Looking Down at Reykjavik
  • Hallgrímskirkja
  • Iceland's Bells
  • Me and Kris' Mini-Tripod
  • Shaggy and Scraggly
  • Steven Wittens
  • That James Walker Smile
  • Is Boris Pondering What I'm Pondering?
  • Blurry Coke-Drinking Me
  • Looking Serious Wearing New Glasses
  • Looking Serious Wearing New Glasses
  • Rain City Bikes at the Vancity Bike Share Launch
  • Canada Day Richard
  • Riding my New Bike
  • In My Snowshoeing Element

Except for quoted text, Just a Gwai Lo is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 2.5 Canada License. A clearly-indicated direct link back to the original article is sufficient attribution. Just a Gwai Lo is powered by Drupal.

  • home
  • about
  • ideas
  • photos
  • cherished
  • shared
  • contact
  • recent